Yes, it is possible for two of the same cigars to taste different. There are several factors that can affect the taste and aroma of a cigar, including the quality of the tobacco, the way the cigar was stored and aged, and even the conditions in which it is smoked.
For example, even if two cigars come from the same box, they may have been rolled by different cigar rollers, which can affect the flavor and aroma. Additionally, if the cigars have been stored in different environments or humidors, they may have absorbed different amounts of moisture or flavors from their surroundings, leading to variations in taste.
Other factors that can affect the taste of a cigar include the age of the tobacco, the size and shape of the cigar, and the way it is cut and lit. As such, even if two cigars are of the same brand and type, they may still have subtle differences in taste and aroma.
It is worth noting that some cigar smokers enjoy the subtle variations in taste and aroma between different cigars, as it adds to the complexity and nuance of the smoking experience. However, if you are looking for a more consistent smoking experience, it is recommended to purchase cigars from a reputable brand and to store them in a proper humidor to maintain their quality and flavor.